Grace wears a watch that tracks her heart rate variability overnight. After a wonderful dinner with her partner, where they laughed and stayed up talking later than they meant to, she wakes to a low number and a note saying her body may be under strain. Grace is a composite of people Dr. Gil has worked with, not an actual patient, and her question is one many of us now ask: is my body telling me something about my relationship that I’m missing? That question is the starting point for understanding heart coherence and what a heart rhythm can and can’t tell you.
In this episode of the Love series, Dr. Gil Winkelman separates three words that often get blurred together: frequency, heart rate variability, and heart coherence. Frequency is how often something repeats. Heart rate variability (HRV) is the variation in timing between heartbeats. So what is heart coherence? It’s a particular pattern in that variation, one that looks like a smooth, regular wave. They are three different things, and the metaphors used earlier in this series, signal and frequency, are checked here against what instruments actually measure.
You’ll hear what moves HRV, including stress, sleep, alcohol, a late meal, caffeine, illness, fitness and age, and why one low reading can’t tell you which of those was responsible. You’ll hear that research links low resting HRV with stress and anxiety, but how strong that link looks depends on how, when and in whom it’s measured. HRV isn’t a mood meter, and it certainly isn’t a love meter. Some medications, such as beta blockers, can also change HRV.
Dr. Gil explains what is well established about breathing and the heart. Heart rate tends to rise on the inhale and fall on the exhale, and slowing your breath to around five or six breaths a minute, which varies from person to person, makes that rise and fall larger and more regular. A smooth wave on a screen is a measurable pattern, not a direct reading of calm, safety or connection. He also describes HRV biofeedback, where you watch your rhythm on a screen while you slow your breathing. Studies suggest it can help with stress and anxiety, though the evidence is disputed in places.
Then he tells you where he stands. Dr. Gil has trained with HeartMath, has used it with patients, and has no financial connection to the company. He explains that its coherence score describes how strongly heart rate variability settles into a particular pattern, which isn’t the same as saying HRV has improved. He shares his own experience, that he felt calmer and freer and learned to notice when he’d slipped out of that state, and his sense that HeartMath may be pointing at something real that science hasn’t caught up to. He offers that as his own belief and experience, and separates it from claims that each emotion has its own rhythm signature or that the heart’s field carries information to other people, which are harder to prove.
For anyone who wears a device, Dr. Gil gives practical guidance: look at trends over weeks, not a single night; notice context like a late dinner, a drink or a short night; don’t check the number to find out how you feel; turn off notifications if it makes you anxious; and talk to your doctor, not an app, if heart rhythm ever worries you. There’s also a thirty-second practice for noticing the difference between a physical sensation and the story that arrives with it. Grace’s good response is neither to throw the watch away nor to obey it. She treats what she felt with her partner and what her watch measured as two different kinds of information.
This is Episode 14 of the Love series on AskDrGil, the first of two episodes on the heart’s rhythm. The next episode looks at what happens between two people. Grace is a composite character. This episode is for education and reflection and isn’t a substitute for professional care.
To see your own patterns more clearly, take the Healing Archetype Quiz at askdrgil.com. And if you recognize something unsaid, a conversation, a boundary or a decision you’ve been putting off, the Permission Session is a private coaching session to get clearer about what you want, what’s holding you back, and what your next step would require: https://askdrgil.com/permission-session/
This episode is for education and reflection. It isn’t a substitute for professional medical or mental health care. If you have a heart condition or any concern about your heart rhythm, talk with your doctor. The Permission Session is coaching, not therapy or medical care. If you’re in crisis in the US, call or text 988.
Leave a Reply